Weekly Photo Challenge: One Shot, Two Ways

Confession: I didn’t read the directions when I decided to post these two pictures. “For this challenge, capture two images — a horizontal and a vertical version — of the same scene or subject.”

What I like best about WordPress challenges is that even when there are instructions, they are flexible. So, I am submitting these two for the challenge: 

But, I also like to follow the rules, so I searched through my images and found these two:

What are your thoughts?